Brick vs. Vinyl vs. Stucco: Pros and Cons of Stucco Finish

If you're building a new home or adding on to your current one, you have a lot of important decisions to make. One of the biggest is choosing the type of siding you'll use.

Not only will this affect the look of your home, but studies show that homes with high curb appeal are worth  7% to 14% more  than similar homes with an uninviting exterior. Cost, durability, and other issues also come into play. 

So how do you decide? Start with understanding the pros and cons of stucco vs. brick vs. vinyl. This way, you can make a decision you'll be happy with for the long-term. Let's take a look at some of the most important things you need to know.

Pros and Cons of Stucco

Stucco siding is a popular option because it can be applied to a variety of surfaces. If you think you might add a  home addition  in the future, it's also one of the easiest to match.

Stucco works well with contemporary home designs and comes in a wide range of colors. It also has moderate fire resistance.

This option is best for dry, hot climates since it can mold or rot in climates where it's always damp. It's also susceptible to cracking and other types of damage. However, this is rare, especially when it's applied by a qualified professional.

In addition, it has a low  insulation R-value , which means it's not as energy-efficient as some other options. Upgrading from a single coat to a triple-coat of stucco can improve the insulation factor.

Vinyl vs. Stucco

When considering the pros and cons of stucco homes vs. vinyl, cost is important.

There are different kinds of vinyl, and the insulated option is more expensive than the non-insulated option. Still, high-end vinyl is about the same cost as low-end stucco. This makes vinyl the more budget-friendly option.

Booth vinyl and stucco are quite durable. However, it's estimated that (with proper care) vinyl will last between 40 and 75 years while stucco can last as long as 60-100 years.

Since stucco doesn't do well in moist climates, this could make vinyl the better choice.

Brick vs. Stucco

When considering the pros and cons of stucco vs brick, cost is often the most important consideration. Although it's very aesthetically pleasing, brick siding is substantially more expensive than stucco. However, it will also give your home a much higher resale value.

It's extremely durable, lasting for more than 100 years when properly maintained. It also requires very little maintenance.

Brick works well with both traditional and modern home styles. However, your color choices are much more limited with brick. If you have a certain color in mind or you want to easily change colors in the future, you may find that stucco is your best choice.

Consult with a Professional

Understanding the pros and cons of stucco vs. vinyl vs. brick is one thing, but actually making the decision is another. If you're still undecided, your best bet is to consult with a professional.

Whether you're thinking about a simple addition or a complete  custom home , the pros at Favinger Contracting are here to help! Contact us today at 267-236-2146 or send us an email at

View All Recent Posts